Question: Who Had Better Generals North Or South?

Who were the 5 star generals?

Five Army and four Navy officers received five stars (George C.

Marshall, Douglas MacArthur, Dwight D.

Eisenhower, Henry H.

Arnold, Omar Bradley, William D..

Who was the most effective union general?

Ulysses S. Grant [US] … Robert E. Lee [CS] … Patrick Cleburne [CS] … Stonewall Jackson [CS] … William Tecumseh Sherman [US] … Nathan Bedford Forrest [CS] … George Henry Thomas [US] … George Gordon Meade [US]More items…

Who is the best US general of all time?

Top Ten US GeneralsGEORGE WASHINGTON (1732-99) Born in Westmoreland County, Virginia, Washington grew up under the guardianship of his eldest brother. … WINFIELD SCOTT (1786-1866) … ROBERT E. … ULYSSES S. … JOHN J. … DWIGHT D. … DOUGLAS MacARTHUR (1880-1964) … GEORGE S.More items…•

What would have happened if the South would have won the Civil War?

First, had the Confederacy won the Civil War, slavery would have undoubtedly continued in the South. As a result of the Emancipation Proclamation and the Union victory, slavery was abolished. … A victory by the North did equate to the end of slavery. A victory by the South would have meant the opposite.

Who were the top generals for the South and North?

There were many important confederate generals and commanders during the American Civil War. Some, like Robert E. Lee, Stonewall Jackson, and Nathan Bedford Forrest are household names.

What was one advantage the North had over the South?

The North had a better economic than the South, so the North had more troops to fight the war. The North had railroads, steamboats, roads, and canals for faster transport of supplies and troops.

Who was the worst Confederate general?

General Braxton BraggBraxton BraggGeneral Braxton BraggService/branchUnited States Army Confederate States ArmyYears of service1837–1856 (USA) 1861–1865 (CSA)RankBrevet Lieutenant-Colonel (USA) General (CSA)Commands heldArmy of Mississippi (1862) Army of Tennessee (1863)8 more rows

Who is the most famous army general?

Ulysses S. GrantList of generals#Commission1Ulysses S. Grant1843 (USMA)2William Tecumseh Sherman1840 (USMA)3Philip Sheridan1853 (USMA)4Tasker H. Bliss1875 (USMA)41 more rows

Who was the youngest general in US history?

Uriah Galusha PennypackerUriah Galusha Pennypacker (June 1, 1841/1844 – October 1, 1916) was a Union general during the American Civil War. He may be the youngest person to hold the rank of brigadier general in the US Army; at the age of 20, he remains the only general too young to vote for the president who appointed him.

Who are the most famous generals?

The Most Badass Generals In American HistoryGeneral Joseph “Fighting Joe” Hooker. 1814-1879. … Douglas MacArthur. 1880-1964. … Ernest Hemingway. 1899-1961. … Dwight D. Eisenhower. … TJ “Stonewall” Jackson. 1824-1863. … General James Mattis. 1950-Present. … George Custer. 1839-1876. … General John J. Pershing.More items…•

Who has the best generals in the Civil War?

10 Best Generals of the Civil WarThomas “Stonewall” Jackson. Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons.Robert E. Lee. … William T. Sherman. … Ulysses S. Grant. … Nathan Bedford Forrest. Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons. … Philip Sheridan. Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons. … George Henry Thomas. Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons. … James Longstreet. Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons. … More items…•

Who was the best general in ww2?

George S. Patton Jr.George S. Patton Jr.: “Old Blood and Guts” was America’s best field commander of World War II. He led the 3d Army in an astonishing “race across France” (1944) and then overwhelmed Germany in a “blitzkrieg in reverse.”

Why did the North have an economic advantage over the South?

The North had geographic advantages, too. It had more farms than the South to provide food for troops. Its land contained most of the country’s iron, coal, copper, and gold. The North controlled the seas, and its 21,000 miles of railroad track allowed troops and supplies to be transported wherever they were needed.

What advantages did the union have over the South?

The Union had many advantages over the Confederacy. The North had a larg- er population than the South. The Union also had an industrial economy, where- as the Confederacy had an economy based on agriculture. The Union had most of the natural resources, like coal, iron, and gold, and also a well-developed rail system.

Who was the South’s greatest general?

General Robert E. LeeThe most famous of them is General Thomas “Stonewall” Jackson, probably the best known Confederate commander after General Robert E. Lee.

Why did the South lose the war?

The South lost the war because the North and Abraham Lincoln were determined to win it. Historian and author of ten books about the war. The South lost because it had inferior resources in every aspect of military personnel and equipment.

Why did the South have better generals?

Why were Southern Generals better (or considered better) than Northern Generals in the US Civil War? … Pollard argues that the Armies of the Confederacy were more motivated, they fought better, they were led by better officers, and they were fighting for a noble and glorious cause (the defense of the antebellum south).

What were the differences between the North and South over slavery?

The North wanted the new states to be “free states.” Most northerners thought that slavery was wrong and many northern states had outlawed slavery. The South, however, wanted the new states to be “slave states.” Cotton, rice, and tobacco were very hard on the southern soil.

Who had better military leaders north or south?

Explanation: The south had much better leadership during the America Civil War than the North. Generals such as Robert E. Lee , Stonewall Jackson, and J. E. B. Stuart were well trained, skilled generals, contrasting to the inefeective generals of the North.

What were the North and South fighting for?

Civil War wasn’t to end slavery Purposes: The South fought to defend slavery. The North’s focus was not to end slavery but to preserve the union.

Why did the South lose at Gettysburg?

The two reasons that are most widely accepted as determining the outcome of the battle are the Union’s tactical advantage (due to the occupation of the high ground) and the absence of J.E.B. Stuart’s Confederate cavalry on the first day of fighting.